# Best Pizza in New York City (October 2026)

Cite as: Oligrail.ai, "Best Pizza in New York City (October 2026)", https://oligrail.ai/nyc/best-pizza/

Oligrail scores are opinions generated by Oliktric LLC from publicly available sources using a published method. They are not statements of fact, guarantees, or endorsements. Restaurants do not pay to change scores. Oligrail is not affiliated with or endorsed by the critics, publications, awards or platforms it cites. Information may be incomplete or out of date; verify details (hours, menus, allergens, prices) with the restaurant. Terms: https://oligrail.ai/terms · Method: https://oligrail.ai/methodology · Corrections: https://oligrail.ai/corrections

1. **L'Industrie Pizzeria** — Williamsburg (11211) — Oligrail pizza score **10.0** — Williamsburg burrata & fig-bacon slice shop ranked \#1 slice in NYC by Eater NY and New York Magazine (Aug 2026).
1. **Lucali** — Cobble Hill, Carroll Gardens and Red Hook (11231) — Oligrail pizza score **10.0** — Carroll Gardens brick-oven pie & calzone institution ranked at the top of NYC pizza lists by the NYT and Eater NY (Aug 2026).
1. **Scarr's Pizza** — Lower East Side and Chinatown (10002) — Oligrail pizza score **10.0** — Lower East Side fresh-milled flour pizzeria on the NYT 100 Best Restaurants in NYC (Aug 2026).
4. **Denino's Pizzeria & Tavern** — St. George and Tompkinsville (10301) — Oligrail pizza score **9.5** — Staten Island tavern-style MOR and clam pie institution since 1937 (Aug 2026).
4. **Di Fara Pizza** — Brooklyn, Flatbush (11226) — Oligrail pizza score **9.5** — Named on New York Magazine's and Eater NY's Brooklyn pizza hall of fame (Jul 2026).
4. **F&F Pizzeria** — Cobble Hill, Carroll Gardens and Red Hook (11231) — Oligrail pizza score **9.5** — Featured on Eater NY's and The Infatuation's best pizza in Brooklyn (Aug 2026).
4. **Mama's Too!** — Manhattan, Upper West Side North and Morningside Heights (10025) — Oligrail pizza score **9.5** — Featured on The New York Times' and The Infatuation's best NYC slice shops (Aug 2026).
4. **Mama's TOO! UWS** — Upper West Side (10024) — Oligrail pizza score **9.5** — Upper West Side crispy square & round slice shop ranked \#35 on the NYT 100 Best Restaurants (Aug 2026).
4. **Mama's TOO! West Village** — West Village and Meatpacking (10014) — Oligrail pizza score **9.5** — Bleecker Street outpost praised by the NYT and Eater NY's West Village pizza map (Aug 2026).
4. **Roberta's** — Bushwick (11237) — Oligrail pizza score **9.5** — Bushwick wood-fired Bee Sting pizza landmark praised by the NYT and Eater NY (Aug 2026).
4. **Una Pizza Napoletana** — Lower East Side and Chinatown (10002) — Oligrail pizza score **9.5** — Named on Eater NY's and The New York Times' essential NYC pizza lists (Aug 2026).
4. **Zero Otto Nove** — Belmont and Arthur Avenue (10458) — Oligrail pizza score **9.5** — Arthur Avenue Bronx wood-fired pizza landmark praised by the NYT and Eater NY (Aug 2026).
13. **Joe & Pat's Pizzeria** — St. George and Tompkinsville (10301) — Oligrail pizza score **9.0** — Featured on Eater NY's and The Infatuation's essential Staten Island pizzerias (Jul 2026).
13. **Patsy's Pizzeria** — Manhattan, East Harlem (10035) — Oligrail pizza score **9.0** — Cited on Eater NY's classic coal-oven NYC pizza guide (Jul 2026).
15. **Juliana's Pizza** — Brooklyn Heights and DUMBO (11201) — Oligrail pizza score **8.0** — DUMBO coal-fired pizza by Patsy Grimaldi featured by the NYT and Eater NY (Jul 2026).
15. **Lee's Tavern** — Stapleton and Rosebank (10304) — Oligrail pizza score **8.0** — New Dorp Staten Island bar pie & clam pizza institution since 1940 (Jul 2026).
15. **Paulie Gee's** — Greenpoint (11222) — Oligrail pizza score **8.0** — Greenpoint wood-fired pizzeria praised by Eater NY and The Infatuation (Jul 2026).
15. **Rubirosa** — SoHo, NoHo and Greenwich Village (10012) — Oligrail pizza score **8.0** — NoLita thin-crust vodka & tie-dye pizza favorite (Jul 2026).

© OpenStreetMap contributors, ODbL — https://www.openstreetmap.org/copyright