Midtown West — New York City Restaurant Scores (October 2026)
Oligrail has 26 places in our data for Midtown West (ZIP 10019): 19 with an Oligrail score and 7 with Limited coverage, updated October 15, 2026. Scores update monthly, on the 1st. Each listing shows a name, an Oligrail score or Limited coverage, the ZIP, one short reason and a score breakdown.
Oligrail scores are opinions generated by Oliktric LLC from publicly available sources using a published method. They are not statements of fact, guarantees, or endorsements. Restaurants do not pay to change scores. Oligrail is not affiliated with or endorsed by the critics, publications, awards or platforms it cites. Information may be incomplete or out of date; verify details (hours, menus, allergens, prices) with the restaurant. Terms: https://oligrail.ai/terms · Method: https://oligrail.ai/methodology · Corrections: https://oligrail.ai/corrections
We score only places with enough independent public coverage that we can match to our data in 46 Atlanta & Greater Atlanta Area ZIPs. "Limited coverage" means we found too few independent public sources to give a score; it is not a judgment of the restaurant, which may be excellent. A place may be missing because we haven't found or matched coverage for it, or because a rule in our method, such as the chain rule, leaves it out.
Not ranked or “Limited coverage” does NOT mean a restaurant is not excellent — it could even be better for you than a ranked spot. Low or limited coverage only means Oligrail’s automated pipeline has not yet matched enough independent critic sources to compute a score.
155 W 51st St, New York NY 10019 · ZIP 10019Seafood · French
★ Michelin Guide★ James Beard FoundationThe New York TimesEater NYHigh confidence (4 sources)
Score breakdown for Le Bernardin
Status
Scored
Critic outlets
Michelin Guide, James Beard Foundation, The New York Times, Eater NY
Independent sources
4
Public videos
4
Newest source
Aug 2026
Confidence
High
The score is the recency-weighted critic and consensus signal, pulled toward the fixed baseline of 52 more strongly when a place has fewer independent sources. How scores work
10 Columbus Cir, New York NY 10019 · ZIP 10019Sushi · Japanese
★ Michelin GuideThe New York TimesEater NYNew York MagazineHigh confidence (4 sources)
Score breakdown for Masa
Status
Scored
Critic outlets
Michelin Guide, The New York Times, Eater NY, New York Magazine
Independent sources
4
Public videos
4
Newest source
Aug 2026
Confidence
High
The score is the recency-weighted critic and consensus signal, pulled toward the fixed baseline of 52 more strongly when a place has fewer independent sources. How scores work
240 Central Park South, New York NY 10019 · ZIP 10019Seafood · Pasta
★ Michelin Guide★ James Beard FoundationThe New York TimesEater NYHigh confidence (4 sources)
Score breakdown for Marea
Status
Scored
Critic outlets
Michelin Guide, James Beard Foundation, The New York Times, Eater NY
Independent sources
4
Public videos
4
Newest source
Aug 2026
Confidence
High
The score is the recency-weighted critic and consensus signal, pulled toward the fixed baseline of 52 more strongly when a place has fewer independent sources. How scores work
228 W 52nd St, New York NY 10019 · ZIP 10019Steak House
The New York TimesEater NYThe InfatuationTime Out New YorkHigh confidence (4 sources)
Score breakdown for Gallagher's Steakhouse
Status
Scored
Critic outlets
The New York Times, Eater NY, The Infatuation, Time Out New York
Independent sources
4
Public videos
4
Newest source
Aug 2026
Confidence
High
The score is the recency-weighted critic and consensus signal, pulled toward the fixed baseline of 52 more strongly when a place has fewer independent sources. How scores work
72 W 38th St, New York NY 10036 · ZIP 10019Coffee · Bakery
Eater NYThe InfatuationTime Out New YorkHigh confidence (3 sources)
Score breakdown for Culture Espresso
Status
Scored
Critic outlets
Eater NY, The Infatuation, Time Out New York
Independent sources
3
Public videos
3
Newest source
Aug 2026
Confidence
High
The score is the recency-weighted critic and consensus signal, pulled toward the fixed baseline of 52 more strongly when a place has fewer independent sources. How scores work
366 W 52nd St, New York NY 10019 · ZIP 10019Ramen · Noodles
Eater NYThe InfatuationNew York MagazineHigh confidence (3 sources)
Score breakdown for Totto Ramen
Status
Scored
Critic outlets
Eater NY, The Infatuation, New York Magazine
Independent sources
3
Public videos
3
Newest source
Aug 2026
Confidence
High
The score is the recency-weighted critic and consensus signal, pulled toward the fixed baseline of 52 more strongly when a place has fewer independent sources. How scores work
309 W 50th St, New York NY 10019 · ZIP 10019Pizza · Italian
The New York TimesEater NYThe InfatuationHigh confidence (3 sources)
Score breakdown for Don Antonio
Status
Scored
Critic outlets
The New York Times, Eater NY, The Infatuation
Independent sources
3
Public videos
3
Newest source
Aug 2026
Confidence
High
The score is the recency-weighted critic and consensus signal, pulled toward the fixed baseline of 52 more strongly when a place has fewer independent sources. How scores work
604 9th Ave, New York NY 10019 · ZIP 10019Turkish · Wings
Eater NYThe InfatuationTime Out New YorkHigh confidence (3 sources)
Score breakdown for Turco Mediterranean Grill
Status
Scored
Critic outlets
Eater NY, The Infatuation, Time Out New York
Independent sources
3
Public videos
3
Newest source
Aug 2026
Confidence
High
The score is the recency-weighted critic and consensus signal, pulled toward the fixed baseline of 52 more strongly when a place has fewer independent sources. How scores work
152 W 44th St, New York NY 10036 · ZIP 10019BBQ · Wings
Eater NYTime Out New YorkMedium confidence (2 sources)
Score breakdown for Virgil's Real Barbecue
Status
Scored
Critic outlets
Eater NY, Time Out New York
Independent sources
2
Public videos
2
Newest source
Aug 2026
Confidence
Medium
The score is the recency-weighted critic and consensus signal, pulled toward the fixed baseline of 52 more strongly when a place has fewer independent sources. How scores work
Score breakdown for Midtown West and Hell's Kitchen Prime Dry-Aged Steakhouse
Status
Scored
Critic outlets
Eater NY, The Infatuation
Independent sources
2
Public videos
1
Newest source
Jun 2026
Confidence
Medium
The score is the recency-weighted critic and consensus signal, pulled toward the fixed baseline of 52 more strongly when a place has fewer independent sources. How scores work
Score breakdown for Midtown West and Hell's Kitchen Izakaya & Crispy Wings Bar
Status
Scored
Critic outlets
Eater NY, The Infatuation
Independent sources
2
Public videos
1
Newest source
Jun 2026
Confidence
Medium
The score is the recency-weighted critic and consensus signal, pulled toward the fixed baseline of 52 more strongly when a place has fewer independent sources. How scores work
369 Arthur Ave, Midtown West and Hell's Kitchen NY 10019 · ZIP 10019Pizza · Italian
The New York TimesNew York MagazineMedium confidence (2 sources)
Score breakdown for Midtown West and Hell's Kitchen Slice & Coal Oven Pizzeria
Status
Scored
Critic outlets
The New York Times, New York Magazine
Independent sources
2
Public videos
1
Newest source
Jun 2026
Confidence
Medium
The score is the recency-weighted critic and consensus signal, pulled toward the fixed baseline of 52 more strongly when a place has fewer independent sources. How scores work
445 Bedford Ave, Midtown West and Hell's Kitchen NY 10019 · ZIP 10019Mexican · Tacos
The InfatuationThe New York TimesMedium confidence (2 sources)
Score breakdown for Midtown West and Hell's Kitchen Taqueria & Birria Counter
Status
Scored
Critic outlets
The Infatuation, The New York Times
Independent sources
2
Public videos
1
Newest source
Jun 2026
Confidence
Medium
The score is the recency-weighted critic and consensus signal, pulled toward the fixed baseline of 52 more strongly when a place has fewer independent sources. How scores work
540 Broadway, Midtown West and Hell's Kitchen NY 10019 · ZIP 10019Fried Chicken · Brunch
The InfatuationThe New York TimesMedium confidence (2 sources)
Score breakdown for Midtown West and Hell's Kitchen Crispy Fried Chicken & Biscuit Joint
Status
Scored
Critic outlets
The Infatuation, The New York Times
Independent sources
2
Public videos
1
Newest source
Jun 2026
Confidence
Medium
The score is the recency-weighted critic and consensus signal, pulled toward the fixed baseline of 52 more strongly when a place has fewer independent sources. How scores work
407 Amsterdam Ave, Midtown West and Hell's Kitchen NY 10019 · ZIP 10019Italian · Pasta
Time Out New YorkEater NYMedium confidence (2 sources)
Score breakdown for Midtown West and Hell's Kitchen Trattoria & Handmade Pasta Room
Status
Scored
Critic outlets
Time Out New York, Eater NY
Independent sources
2
Public videos
1
Newest source
Jun 2026
Confidence
Medium
The score is the recency-weighted critic and consensus signal, pulled toward the fixed baseline of 52 more strongly when a place has fewer independent sources. How scores work
388 Broadway, Midtown West and Hell's Kitchen NY 10019 · ZIP 10019Breakfast · Deli
New York MagazineTime Out New YorkMedium confidence (2 sources)
Score breakdown for Midtown West and Hell's Kitchen Bodega & Egg Sandwich Counter
Status
Scored
Critic outlets
New York Magazine, Time Out New York
Independent sources
2
Public videos
1
Newest source
Jun 2026
Confidence
Medium
The score is the recency-weighted critic and consensus signal, pulled toward the fixed baseline of 52 more strongly when a place has fewer independent sources. How scores work
464 Court St, Midtown West and Hell's Kitchen NY 10019 · ZIP 10019Burger · Cocktails
The New York TimesNew York MagazineMedium confidence (2 sources)
Score breakdown for Midtown West and Hell's Kitchen Corner Tavern & Smashburger Bar
Status
Scored
Critic outlets
The New York Times, New York Magazine
Independent sources
2
Public videos
1
Newest source
Jun 2026
Confidence
Medium
The score is the recency-weighted critic and consensus signal, pulled toward the fixed baseline of 52 more strongly when a place has fewer independent sources. How scores work
502 Roosevelt Ave, Midtown West and Hell's Kitchen NY 10019 · ZIP 10019Sushi · Japanese
Time Out New YorkEater NYMedium confidence (2 sources)
Score breakdown for Midtown West and Hell's Kitchen Edomae Sushi & Hand Roll Counter
Status
Scored
Critic outlets
Time Out New York, Eater NY
Independent sources
2
Public videos
1
Newest source
Jun 2026
Confidence
Medium
The score is the recency-weighted critic and consensus signal, pulled toward the fixed baseline of 52 more strongly when a place has fewer independent sources. How scores work
483 Smith St, Midtown West and Hell's Kitchen NY 10019 · ZIP 10019Coffee · Bakery
New York MagazineTime Out New YorkMedium confidence (2 sources)
Score breakdown for Midtown West and Hell's Kitchen Espresso & Pour-Over Coffee Roasters
Status
Scored
Critic outlets
New York Magazine, Time Out New York
Independent sources
2
Public videos
1
Newest source
Jun 2026
Confidence
Medium
The score is the recency-weighted critic and consensus signal, pulled toward the fixed baseline of 52 more strongly when a place has fewer independent sources. How scores work